Sports Lawyers Assess Arda Kardesler’s ‘Bitcoin Crisis’ at Cumhuriyet.com.tr

An investigation has been launched against Arda Brothers, who took part in the fight between Beşiktaş and Fenerbahce in the 35th week of the Super League. The Turkish Football Federation (TFF) has announced that an investigation has been launched against Arda Brothers, who used Bitcoin in tossing pre-match coins.

Announcing that the coin toss in Derby was done without the knowledge of TFF and MHK, the federation launched an investigation against Arda Brothers.

The following statements were made in the TFF statement:

“It has been revealed to the public that the referee of the Beşiktaş-Fenerbahçe match in the 36th week of the Sport Toto Super League Ahmet driver season tossed coins without the knowledge and approval of Arda Brothers, TFF and MHK. We strongly oppose it. We respectfully present it to the public. “

“Not in line with international guidelines”

Charshi case lawyer Ali Riza Dijdar and lawyer Guru Gunal and Dr. About Ender Ege Cumhuriyet.com.trHe made a statement.

Attorney Ali Riza Dijdar

Attorney Ali Riza Dijdar commented that the use of Bitcoin instead of Arda Brothers coins was “unethical” and added:

“The use of Bitcoin by Arda Kardesler is not in accordance with international law. Bitcoin is an advertising currency. Sports guidelines are international. We are bound by FIFA and UEFA rules. It is an advertising currency. A referee cannot advertise on the field. He must be neutral. “

“If the ethics committee sentences men to more than 6 months, their trial is over.”

Disder said the matter must go to the ethics committee. “If the ethics committee imposes a ban for more than six months, Cordesler’s refereeing life is over. I think he was aware of the mistake. The ethics committee must impose a penalty.” Used expressions.

Attorney Gunal on the body

Another lawyer, Guru Gay Gunal, who evaluated the investigation, underlined that there was no clear definition of throwing a coin in FIFA’s guidelines and said:

  • The rules of the game are determined by FIFA The FIFA and IFAB guidelines do not have a clear definition of what a currency toss means. However, there are examples taken by federations of different countries with the events that have developed over time. For example, a referee who started playing with an application in the form of rock scissors and paper instead of flipping a coin was punished with deprivation by the English Football Federation. Here, it is necessary to make a guess based on the universal rules of law and explain them literally by reversing the currency in FIFA rules.

Gunal concludes by saying that it is against the law to throw a coin with Bitcoin:

  • “Bitcoin, referred to as a digital currency, first appeared in 2009, and FIFA’s regulation on the throwing of a coin is a rule that took place many years ago in the rules of the game. There is still no concept like digital currency and bitcoin ৷ the word coin in this regulation only includes coins with head on one side and inscription on one side অর্ in this sense, if the rules of the game are literally interpreted, it is against the rules to throw bitcoin. Only coins with head and tail can be used in coin toss made for coin toss.

In answer to our question about the sports lawyer. Önder Ege, on the other hand, cites the rules of football published by FIFA and makes the following statement:

  • The TFF’s investigation into the Arda Brothers has considered two issues. First, how does the game start and what does it mean to toss coins? The rules for the 2021-2022 football game, published by FIFA, explain in detail how the referee will start the game. According to paragraph 1 of paragraph 8 of this booklet, the team that wins the toss chooses the attacking goal or kick-off in the first half. What is meant by money here is not the universally known currency, but the meaning of the game. The game coin has a ball on one side and a ruck on the other. This is a traditional currency toss method that FIFA has probably been using since its inception. If there are no such coins, then regular coins can be tossed.

Dr. The leader is Aegean

Ege says the TFF guidelines do not contain a detailed article on the transfer of funds and states:

  • When we look at the incident from a Turkish perspective, we need to examine the TFF’s instructions. When we look at the TFF Football Competition Guidelines and the Referee Assistant Referee Handbook, there is a rule regarding the referee coin toss in paragraph 1 of Article 5. This rule explains that the assistant referees must have match money and the toss will be with this match money. The meaning of this match is the currency used by FIFA. There is no statement in the Referee Assistant Referee Handbook about what to do if this money is not available. When we look at the instructions of the football competition and the instructions of the Central Referee Board, there are no explanatory rules in Turkey about how referees will toss money. Coins are said to have been tossed, but no coins have been used to explain how the toss was made. In particular, the provisions of the TFF do not specify that money cannot be used There is no investigation file that we can take as an example, because such an incident has never happened before.

Thinking that referee Arda Cardesler would not receive a severe punishment, Wonder Edge ended his sentence as follows:

  • I don’t think Arda Brothers will be severely punished. Here’s the thing to look for: Can this be considered a secret ad? Can this be interpreted by the referee as a violation of fair play rules? But to be punished must be a crime. The TFF guidelines do not explicitly state that cryptocurrencies cannot be used. I don’t think there will be disciplinary action, but there may be a warning for non-compliance with Fair Play. But after that it is a matter of issuing circulars. The referees will have to abide by the circular from now on.

Leave a Comment